Sawyer plays the other side of the tape, which is Ben saying they don't have time to get samples and to just mark the tents of the pregnant women.
At the Others' tent camp, Locke wants to know who Ben answers to. Ben says Jacob and Locke wants Ben to take him to see Jacob. Ben says he can't do that.
Mikhail comes running into camp and wonders what Locke is doing there. He says that Locke's people found a woman who parachuted onto the island. They have to go to their camp.
Locke says they can't because Ben is taking him to see Jacob. Everyone stops and stares and Ben looks nervous.
Ben tells Locke it will have to wait and Mikhail wants to know why Ben is explaining himself to Locke.
Locke attacks Mikhail, and despite Ben's pleas, no one comes to Mikhail's rescue.
While Ben and Locke fill their canteens at a stream, Alex comes and gives Locke a gun. She says that if they are going to see Jacob, Locke will need a gun. She sarcastically wishes her father a happy birthday.
Locke and Ben go into some old ruins and Ben talks to an empty chair as if Jacob is there. Locke tells Ben that he doesn't know anything and he is pathetic. He opens the door, but hears a strange voice say, "Help me."
He asks Ben what he said and turns around and shines the flashlight on Ben.
Suddenly the door closes, the room shakes, the lantern falls on the ground and starts a fire, and windows break. Ben grabs the chair and tells Jacob that he's had his fun.
For a moment, it looks like someone is sitting in the chair. Locke goes outside and shuts the door.
Ben asks what Jacob said to him, and Locke says it was Ben who had said it.
Ben takes Locke to a mass grave and tells him that that's his people. That's the Dharma Initiative. He shoots Locke and Locke falls into the grave.
"What did Jacob tell you?" Ben asks.
Locke says that Jacob said, 'Help me.'