Hurley plans a picnic for Libby, but everything keeps going wrong. First he tries to get a radio from Sayid, but that doesn't work. Then she catches him as he gathers food. They get lost in the jungle and he leads them to a "secret beach," which turns out to be their own beach. He doesn't have blankets or drinks. Libby sends him to find wine and she goes to get some blankets.
Ana-Lucia gives non-Henry food and he attacks her. He would have killed her, but Locke hits him on the head with his crutch. Later, Locke asks why he attacked Ana-Lucia, but he didn't attack Locke when Locke was caught under the blast door. Non-Henry says it is because Locke is a good person and non-Henry had been coming there to get Locke when he was captured.
Ana-Lucia asks Sawyer for a gun, but he won't give it to her. She sleeps with him and steals his gun. When everyone leaves the hatch, she goes in to shoot non-Henry, but can't do it. Michael says that he will do it and she gives him the gun and the combination to the armory. He apologizes and then shoots Ana-Lucia. Libby walks in and he shoots her too. He opens the armory, looks at non-Henry, and shoots himself in the arm.
